Evaluate the roof before choosing materials
Start with the condition of the existing roof and the reasons a replacement is being considered. Ask the roofer to explain the assessment and any areas that need closer review. The appearance of the roof covering is one part of the decision.
Discuss how the proposed system fits your roof’s shape, slope, and structure. Ask whether the work includes reviewing the deck, ventilation, flashing, and drainage.
Compare the complete roofing system
Asphalt shingles, metal, tile, slate, and other materials have different installation requirements. Low-slope roof systems need a separate comparison. Our roofing material selector includes reference images and questions to discuss for 15 categories.
- Roof covering and specified product.
- Underlayment, flashing, and roof penetrations.
- Ventilation and drainage details.
- How concealed damage will be handled if found.
Read the estimate as a scope of work
Compare what each proposal includes, rather than the total alone. Roof size, complexity, access, removal of old materials, and underlying repairs can affect the estimate. Ask which quantities and specifications the roofer has used.
The written proposal should explain removal and disposal, installation, property protection, cleanup, possible additional work, payment terms, and applicable warranty coverage. Clarify changes before work begins.
Plan the project and final review
Discuss scheduling, material delivery, access to your property, and how weather changes will be communicated. Ask what you need to move or protect and how the crew will handle cleanup.
At the final walkthrough, review the completed scope, remaining questions, care instructions, and warranty documents. Prime Home Exterior connects homeowners with roofers across all 50 states. You can prepare your ZIP code and project needs in our downloadable project details form; online submission is not yet enabled.